Why Ruby Chocolate Is Fake

ruby chocolate con

Ruby chocolate has been dubbed the 4th chocolate after dark, milk and white by it’s creators. How ruby chocolate is made is a secret but a bit of research uncovers all is not what it seems.

fresh cocoa pod

Ruby Cocoa Beans

This refers to a cocoa bean that has been processed to make ruby chocolate. There’s not a newly discovered variety of cocoa bean called ruby and the marketing around this product is misleading. Ruby cocoa beans are made from the same regular cocoa beans.

Cocoa beans grow in a purple pod and when unprocessed they have a purple tint. The purple colour is usually lost after fermenting so a change in this process could retain the purple colour that becomes pink once mixed into the final ruby chocolate. A patent from the makers of ruby chocolate indicates less processing is involved.

This colour is probably from less fermenting. Because it’s a niche product ruby chocolate costs more although less work is involved. Similar to the difference between cocoa and cacao and why cacao is more expensive.

Ruby chocolate has none of the deep cacao taste you expect of chocolate, indicating it hasn’t been fermented to develop the complex flavour tones.

kit kat ruby cocoa beans

Eating With Your Eyes

When you taste food you don’t just use the sense of taste. Your other sensory functions of look and smell also affect the taste, weird but true.

When an artificial flavour is created they spend more time on the aroma than the actual flavour as the smell is interpreted by the brain and does significantly change the flavour. If you don’t believe me, try eating a meal with a peg on your nose and see how different it tastes.

Eating with your eyes is relevant to ruby chocolate as people (in my limited research) often say it tastes like berries and fruit. However if you taste it without looking the flavour is described as more of a tangy and sour.

Ruby chocolate has very little cocoa flavour so some see it as a cost-cutting product to make more money as lower grade cocoa beans could be used.

ruby chocolate taste

Ruby Chocolate Recipe

The secret ingredient, that’s not so secret as it’s on the packet, for ruby chocolate is citric acid.

Ruby Chocolate Ingredients (Sugar, Cocoa Butter, Skimmed Milk Powder, Whole Milk Powder, Cocoa Mass, Emulsifier: Soya Lecithin, Acid: Citric Acid, Natural Vanilla Flavouring)

Ruby Chocolate contains Cocoa Solids 47% minimum and Milk Solids 26% minimum

This citric acid gives it the sour tangy flavour that many think tastes like berries as their brain sees the pink colour and berries are very acidic.

Many people have confused raspberry white chocolate with ruby chocolate. The whole point of ruby chocolate is that nothing is added to colour and flavour it. While the colour can be naturally achieved via processing a flavouring has almost certainly been added with the citric acid. Meaning ruby chocolate isn’t really much different to the similar looking chocolates that have existed for a long time, possibly worse as it doesn’t contain any real fruit.

I don’t want to stifle innovation, but ruby chocolate does seem to be a marketing ploy in the world of looking for ever more instagramable food.

Not all ingredients used during processing are listed on the label as if they’re under a certain amount and lost during processing they aren’t required to be listed by many countries legislation. 

kit kat ruby chocolate ingredients

Ruby Chocolate Kit Kat

The only mass market product that contains ruby chocolate is the ruby Kit Kat by Nestle. This bar has added flavourings that really renders the whole point of this “new taste sensation” pointless.

The ruby kit kat is widely available in Tesco stores across the UK and has had a very mixed reception. Maybe the makers of ruby chocolate have struggled to get much attention for the alleged 4th chocolate as a high-quality premium ingredient so did a deal with Nestle to avoid stocks going to waste.

ruby chocolate bar

Vegan Ruby Chocolate

Ruby chocolate is very similar to white chocolate as it’s mainly cocoa butter, sugar and milk. As only the one company (callebaut) makes one variety of couverture ruby chocolate it’s not vegan. There has been talk of a vegan variety of ruby chocolate in the future but nothing is available at the moment.

TLDR Ruby Chocolate

Ruby chocolate is just less processed white chocolate that retains the purple / pink natural colour and has some citric acid added to give sour undertones and trick the brain. It’s made by one company that’s very secretive and lots of the press around ruby chocolate has been misleading.

Let me know in the comments below what you think about my article on ruby chocolate. I thought it would be interesting to talk about it as couldn’t see anywhere exposing it for what it actually is – marketing. It’s certainly not a healthy product as it’s the main ingredient is refined sugar.

Tags:

6 thoughts on “Why Ruby Chocolate Is Fake”

  1. actually everything in Barry ruby chocolate is all natural. despite your thoughts on the citric acid addition it is only to enhance the flavor of fruit that is already there. if you actually knew about chocolate you’d know that even dark chocolates, depending on how they are made, can have a very fruit forward flavor. this process has been cultivated by one of the world best chocolate makers to be a fruit forward chocolate. this is a legit new type of chocolate, not a marketing ploy. the kitkat aside.

    1. Hi there, I’m not saying that the added ingredient citric acid isn’t natural as of course it is. What I’m saying is the addition of citric acid that’s giving the fruity flavour, rather than anything naturally contained in the chocolate. Without the added citric acid there would only be the same subtle fruity tones that lots of chocolate already has. Although if you have new information to disprove what I think about ruby chocolate please do share it.

  2. Kathleen Sutherland

    Thanks for exposing the ploy that this is. Citric acid will create an artificial fruity flavor. I’ve found an XoXo brand ruby chocolate bar that does not contain citric acid, and it has a very mild berry flavor, but otherwise is quite similar to white chocolate – sweet and creamy. It occurs to me, since I love a very mild milk chocolate, that I could create a similar confection just by melting down milk chocolate with white chocolate.

    What might be interesting is to try just ruby cocoa powder, the powder of the beans, without the addition or manipulation of other ingredients. it probably wouldn’t taste very good, which is why it might not ever become available. But if ruby cocoa beans are truly something new and unique, then the cocoa powder would be fun to cook with: brownies, cakes, etc.

  3. Did you read the patent? First of all, white chocolate does not contain cocoa solids. Ruby does. That make sit inherently different from white chocolate. The citric acid is a super tiny fraction of the recipe, and it is there to preserve colour, just as you would use lemon juice to prevent an apple or avocado from oxidation. I’m not really a super big Ruby fan, but this article is pretty misinformed.

    1. Hi there, yes I’ve had fresh slimy cocoa beans and cocoa beans fermented with the white fleshy bit. I didn’t really taste much of a berry flavour. Yes it has cocoa powder but a tiny amount to give a pinky colour from what I can tell. Red / purple cocoa powder isn’t a new invention and has been around for a long time. Adding a tiny bit to a white chocolate to give a colour doesn’t really seem like a new invention to me. I still think the fruity taste comes from the citric acid. But I’m happy to be proved wrong – was there any bit of the patient you’re referring to?

  4. Oh, I should add, that if you have ever tasted a cacoa fruit fresh from the tree, the fruity notes of ruby taste a lot like that.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *